Felicity's diary was found to contain her phone number: +1-252-588-3964. Felicity had discarded the SIM card while on the run on the US east coast in mid-2023, leaving us with voicemail messages she will never check herself.

The voicemail was originally discovered on July 27, 2023, full and no longer accepting new messages.

Caller: Felicity's dad

This is your dad. I read that… that contract. Four words: do not sign it. I… I don’t know what you’re trying to apply for, what you’re trying to do, but this is… this is a very bad idea. Uh, give me a call. Call me.

Caller: Felicity's dad

Your mom and I expected a phone call, but… I guess you’re too good for us these days. Haven’t heard from you in a while. Better not have signed that paper.

Caller: Robocall

This is Seashore Pharmacy, letting you know your prescription starting with Z-O-L-O is ready for pickup. Our pharmacy hours are 9am to 5pm, Monday through Thursday. Your copay is five dollars.

Caller: Felicity's dad

Uhh… your mom and I, we… we went on an app, uh, can’t remember what it’s called, somethin’… somethin’ gram… wait, no, Insta-face
[background yelling INSTAGRAM!]
Uh, Insta… Instagram! Alright, Instagram. Anyway, um… I guess, um… you signed that contract, um… would have been nice to at least say goodbye before your trip. I hope everything’s okay.

Caller: Felicity's dad

Uh, your mom saw your… Insta…
[background yelling INSTAGRAM!]
Uh… Instagram you made, uh, hope you have a good trip but could’ve said goodbye before you go, really worrying your mom. I guess we’ll see you in six months? Would have been nice to let us know we had to watch Chewie for that long. He’s gonna miss you. Not like you spend that much time with him anyway. Okay, call us when you get back.

Caller: Desiree Martin

Hey. Um, this is Desiree. I am not sure where you are or if you are getting this message but please call me. I am not sure why we can’t find you on the island and if you went back home but I really need to talk to you. I hope everything is okay. You can reach me at 16067220004 extension 39248. You probably won’t be able to call the number I am calling from. Talk to you soon.

Caller: Robocall

Dixie PCS. Your automatic payment of seventy six dollars twenty three cents was declined by the credit or debit card on file ending in 2928. Please make a payment immediately, otherwise, your service will be suspended. Thank you for being a valued customer of Dixie PCS.

Caller: Desiree Martin

Hey. Desiree here. I don’t know if you remember, but the contract was for six months. You weren’t even here a month. I am not sure if you didn’t like the island, or something happened, but we really need to talk. Maybe we can work something out, but we want to make sure you are okay. You can reach me at 16067220004 extension 39248. Don’t try to call the Iridium number back.

Caller: Robocall

This is Ocracoke Mutual. Your auto insurance policy ending in 391840 on your 2021 Jeep Wrangler has been cancelled due to non-payment on this policy. For more information, or to reinstate your policy, please contact your insurance agent.

Caller: Felicity's dad

It’s… it’s your mom and dad, look, look honey, I don’t know what happened, or you got caught up in something, or what you stole or did, but, if you need a lawyer… we… we can help you. Don’t talk to these people, look… uh, just call us, uh, we’ll figure it out, come over, uh, whatever you want to do, uh, I can pick you up where… wherever, you don’t have to drive all this way, um, or take the ferry… just, just call us, or, uh, send me a Insta… Instagram.

Caller: Desiree Martin

It’s Desiree again. I think there was a huge misunderstanding. It’s okay if you don’t want the job anymore. Just call me back so we can send your last paycheck to you. We just need a current address. You can reach me at 16067220004 extension 39248. You can also try to call back the satellite number if you want. We just need to talk.

Caller: David

Felicity. These people showed up to my house, looking for my “girlfriend”. Actually, it’s worse than that. I came home and they were talking to my girlfriend about you as my “lover” asking where you were for two fucking hours. Dude, this is not okay. She now thinks I’m cheating on her with you. This is not cool. I got them to leave once I finally convinced them I have no idea where the hell you are. Carla is pissed at me. I have no idea what the hell you did, what you stole or what you got caught up in, or who the hell Jeff is, but don’t ever put me down as your emergency contact, friend, lover, or whatever the hell you told you. Like I told you a million times, get the hell out of my life.

Caller: David

Felicity. I don’t know what your grand plan was, but Carla left me. Yeah. That stunt you pulled screwed up my relationship with her. I don’t know… I hope they throw you in jail.

Caller: Unknown

I’m sorry for the voice changer, I’m not trying to scare you, this is for my own protection, this isn’t like a scary movie or anything like that. I don’t know if you got a new phone or anything, and you’re lucky to get out of there alive. We’re helped– we’re the people who helped you. Now, if you didn’t get a new phone, and you’re listening to this voicemail, after you listen to this, I need you to throw it out the window, leave it somewhere, get as far away as possible from it. They have your number and they have ways of locating phones. And trust me, let’s just say you really, really, really, really don’t want them to find you. I wouldn’t even risk it with a burner phone or anything, like I told you before in the message I sent you, so keep things [???]. The [???] cash should get you by for a while, but don’t do anything crazy because we won’t be able to get you any more. Don’t spend too much, keep a low profile, keep a budget, and keep things moving. I can’t stress that enough - keep moving. If you can get a jumper… junker car or something, something really old, maybe from the 80s, trust me, there are ways of tracking people that would keep your… make your head spin. Maybe you could have fun on a road trip or something, but don’t fly, don’t use credit cards, no debit cards, don’t do anything that could be tracked before we stop these people. They deserve to be behind bars or worse. Maybe with enough time they’ll give up on you if they don’t see any trace of you. They got [???]. Look, one other thing, I need you to check into [???], you’re going to be using a payphone, so buy one of those. You know the one, right, the ones that you put the money into. Anyway, you’re gonna use a public payphone, an old phone, ask to use a phone, use an old cell phone, and you’re gonna dial a number. Once we get that set up, we’re still working on that one, sorry, but we’re still working on this one. After this, hang up and go. Do this once a week on Sunday or something. I’m gonna get– come up with some way of getting you this number, okay. If, but, if a few weeks go by, and we don’t get a check-in once you get the number, we’re gonna assume something happened to you. And we don’t want that, obviously, but we have to know either way. And look, none of this is your fault, don’t be scared, we’re watching things pan out on our side, and also remember what I told you about the OTP22 people. Be careful, but reach out to them, and try to get some of the documents you have to them. And maybe there could be a liaison or something once we figure out even how to do that. I think we can trust them, but be careful. And I wish you the best of luck. And remember, I don’t care how much you spent on this phone, if it was an iPhone or whatever you got for your new phone, but toss this thing somewhere. [???], obviously, fully charged, [???] a rest stop or something, so they won’t be able to follow your trail. Good luck.

On September 20, 2023, it was discovered that Felicity's voicemail has been upgraded, cleared of all previous messages and now accepting new ones.

Caller: Robocall

Dixie PCS. This line has been upgraded to Voicemail Plus, effective immediately. You now have unlimited message storage. Enjoy.

SSTV images; see Slide Cemetery drop.

Caller: Emtanon employee

Background noise and ABISM tones (N!SECURITY!REPORT!19092). Halfway through, a male voice says This damn thing.

Caller: Emtanon employee

Background noise and ABISM tones (TIONAL!BANDWITH!OVER!SIDEBAND!ON!B4!B7!AND!B12!TRANSPONDERS!ON!DS).

On October 6, six new SSTV images were found, depicting the Tuktoyaktuk drop.

On October 18, two new SSTV images were found, depicting the Riverside drop.